|
Air coming out of wastewater treatment plants (WWTP) always contains H2S (Hydrogen Sulphide) and Total Reduced Sulphur compounds (TRS) such as DMS (Dimethyl Sulphide) or MM(Methyl Mercaptins). Reducing H2S does not assure the removal of bad odors from the air since TRS contributes significantly to odor problems even in very low concentrations. Simply cutting H2S amounts in half is not likely to be a noticeable reduction in smell.
A very effective way of treating this smelly air is by using biotrickling filters (used for high concentrations of H2S) followed by biofilters (where total odor removal is required). Both a biotrickling filter and biofilter are made up of a media upon which grows naturally occurring bacteria. By passing this air through the media the bacteria digests the contaminants in the air that contributes to odor thus purifying the air. Biotricklers are able to handle very high concentrations of H2S while biofilters handle lower concentrations but are also able to handle the TRS. The two biggest advantages of using these technologies are that there are no environmental side effects and that total odor removal is achievable.
Biofilters are also able to handle other compounds such as Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC’s). This widens the use of these technologies into many other areas such as composting plants, industrial plants and energy from waste plants where odor and other pollutants need to be removed from air.
Technology Comparison
| |
Pros |
Cons |
| Biotrickling Filter |
Excellent for high H2S
Low operating Cost
|
Does not assure total odor removal |
| Biofilter |
Excellent at total odor
Very low operating Cost |
Not meant for high H2S loadings
Higher capital cost |
| Wood Chip Biofilter |
Moderate capital Cost |
Performance degrades very quickly
Media must be changed out every 2-3 years
|
| Ozone |
Low capital Cost |
Requires very high residency time to be effective
No verifiable data available
Few valid applications |
| Chemical Scrubber |
Low capital Cost |
Very high operating cost
Creates chemical waste stream
|
| Carbon Filters |
Low capital cost
Effective at total odor
|
Significant operating cost (media change out 1yr to 3yr)
Performance degrades and odor problem returns
|
| Thermal Oxidizers |
Low capital Cost |
High contribution to Green House Gas
High operating costs
High maintenance costs
|
|